Direct Answer

The USAA Cashback Rewards Plus American Express ($0 annual fee) is superior for eligible military members, veterans, and military families who spend up to $3,000 annually on gas stations and military base commissaries/exchanges, earning an exceptional 5% cash back. The Citi Double Cash ($0 annual fee) is superior for all non-military households and for any household spending heavily across general non-bonus categories, earning an unlimited 2% cash back (1% when buying, 1% when paying).

  • USAA Cashback Rewards Plus ($0 AF) earns 5% cash back on gas station and military base commissary/exchange spend (up to $3,000/yr)
  • Citi Double Cash ($0 AF) earns an unlimited 2% cash back (1% when you buy, 1% as you pay) across all purchase categories
  • Spending exactly $3,000 per year on gas/commissary on the USAA card yields $150 cash back vs. $60 on the Citi Double Cash
  • USAA eligibility is restricted to active-duty military, veterans, and their immediate family members; Citi is open to general public

Head-to-Head Comparison

FeatureUSAA Cashback Rewards Plus American Express®Citi® Double Cash Card
Annual Fee$0$0
Gas Station Purchases5% Cash Back (up to $3,000/yr combined)2% Cash Back
Military Base Spend5% Cash Back (Commissary, Exchange, Shoppette)2% Cash Back
Supermarket Purchases2% Cash Back (up to $3,000/yr combined)2% Cash Back
All Other Purchases1% Cash Back2% Cash Back (1% buy, 1% pay)
Cap on 5% Spending$3,000 per calendar yearNone (unlimited 2%)
Eligibility RestrictionUSAA Membership Required (Military/Veterans)None (Open to all qualified applicants)
Foreign Transaction Fee0%3%
Transferable Points OptionCash back onlyConverts to ThankYou Points

Mathematical Crossover Analysis

On gas and military base spend up to $3,000 per year:

  • USAA earns: $$3,000 \times 5% = $150.00$
  • Citi Double Cash earns: $$3,000 \times 2% = $60.00$
  • USAA Advantage on Gas: $+$90.00$

On all general non-bonus spending: Citi Double Cash earns an extra 1.0% cash back ($0.01 per dollar) over USAA’s 1.0% base rate:

$$\text{General Spend Crossover} = \frac{\$90.00}{0.01} = \$9,000$$

If you spend more than $9,000 annually on non-bonus purchases outside of gas, Citi Double Cash generates more total annual dollars than the USAA card on a single-card setup.

Strategic Verdict

— The Optimal Dual-Card Play: Eligible military families should carry both cards. Put all fuel and on-base commissary/exchange spending on the USAA Cashback Rewards Plus up to the $3,000 cap ($150 cash back), and put all other everyday purchases on the Citi Double Cash for an unlimited 2% return.

Recommended Cards for This Strategy