Direct Answer

Robinhood Gold ($50/yr) leads on all uncategorized spending with an unmatched flat 3% cash back. Amex Blue Cash Everyday ($0 AF) wins for households whose spend is concentrated in U.S. supermarkets, online retail, and gas stations up to $6,000/yr per category.

  • Amex Blue Cash Everyday earns 3% on US Supermarkets, US Online Retail, and US Gas Stations ($6k cap each, $0 AF)
  • Robinhood Gold earns 3% flat cash back with zero category caps, zero merchant restrictions, and no foreign transaction fees
  • The Breakeven Math: Spending over $1,667/yr on non-bonus categories (medical, utilities, auto repairs, tuition) pays for Robinhood Gold's $50 annual fee
  • Blue Cash Everyday includes up to $84 in annual Disney Bundle credits with a permanent $0 annual fee

Head-to-Head Comparison

FeatureRobinhood Gold CardAmerican Express Blue Cash Everyday
Annual Cost$50/yr (Robinhood Gold subscription)$0 annual fee
Base Cash Back3% cash back on all spend1% cash back
U.S. Supermarkets3% cash back (uncapped)3% cash back (up to $6,000/yr, then 1%)
U.S. Online Retail3% cash back (uncapped)3% cash back (up to $6,000/yr, then 1%)
U.S. Gas Stations3% cash back (uncapped)3% cash back (up to $6,000/yr, then 1%)
Travel Portal5% cash back via Robinhood Travel1% cash back
Foreign Transaction Fee$0 (None)2.7%
Network TierVisa SignatureAmerican Express Traditional

Mathematical Spending Analysis: Which Card Wins?

The choice between these two cards comes down to where your money goes outside the big three consumer categories:

  1. When Amex Blue Cash Everyday Wins: If your non-housing expenses are almost exclusively groceries, Amazon/online shopping, and gas, and your total spend in each category stays under $6,000 per year ($500/month), the Blue Cash Everyday earns $540 per year with zero annual fee. Because Robinhood Gold requires a $50/year Gold subscription, Amex yields a higher net return on low, concentrated budgets.

  2. When Robinhood Gold Card Wins: If you have substantial spending on medical bills, car maintenance, daycare, home renovations, dining, streaming, or utility bills, Amex Blue Cash Everyday drops to a meager 1%.

    $$\text{Net Benefit} = (\text{Spend}_{\text{non-bonus}} \times 0.03) - 50$$

    Spending just $1,667 per year ($139/month) on miscellaneous non-bonus purchases on Robinhood Gold generates $50 in cash back, completely erasing the subscription cost. Beyond that break-even threshold, every dollar earns 3x more than Amex.

The Verdict & Dual-Card Strategy

  • Best Standalone Zero-Fee Card: American Express Blue Cash Everyday.
  • Best High-Volume Cash Back Driver: Robinhood Gold Card.
  • Optimal Dual-Card Strategy: Use Amex Blue Cash Everyday for the $84 annual Disney Bundle credit ($7/month statement credit) and keep Robinhood Gold as your daily primary driver for 3% cash back on every other transaction.

Recommended Cards for This Strategy

Robinhood $0/yr

Robinhood Gold Card

Base Return 3.0%
Full Card Breakdown →
American Express $0/yr

Amex Blue Cash Everyday

Base Return 1.0%
Top Category 3x / %
Full Card Breakdown →