Direct Answer

The Amex Blue Cash Preferred ($95 AF, waived year one) wins for households spending up to $6,000 annually ($500/month) on U.S. supermarkets (6% cash back = $360 rewards, net $265 after fee). The Robinhood Gold Card ($0 AF with $50/yr Robinhood Gold subscription) wins if your non-category everyday spend exceeds $8,833 annually or if your grocery spend exceeds $6,000, earning an uncapped flat 3% on every purchase.

  • Amex Blue Cash Preferred earns 6% cash back on U.S. supermarkets (up to $6,000/year, then 1%) and select streaming
  • Robinhood Gold Card earns an unconditional flat 3% cash back on all spend with zero category caps
  • BCP charges a $95 annual fee after year one, while Robinhood Gold requires an active $50/yr subscription
  • Break-even: If your household non-grocery spend exceeds $750/month, Robinhood Gold's 3% yields higher annual net cash back

Head-to-Head Comparison

FeatureRobinhood Gold CardAmex Blue Cash Preferred®
Annual Fee$0 (Requires $50/yr or $5/mo Gold membership)$0 intro for first year, then $95/year
U.S. Supermarkets Multiplier3% Cash Back (Uncapped)6% Cash Back (Capped at $6,000/yr, then 1%)
U.S. Streaming Multiplier3% Cash Back6% Cash Back (Uncapped)
Transit / Gas Multiplier3% Cash Back3% on Gas & Transit (tolls, rideshares, trains)
Everyday Non-Category Spend3% Cash Back (Uncapped)1% Cash Back
Foreign Transaction Fee0% (None)2.7% of each transaction after conversion
Network & AcceptanceVisa Signature (Accepted worldwide)American Express (Limited international acceptance)

Mathematical Break-Even Analysis

To determine which card delivers superior net return, compare maximum grocery value against general non-category spending:

  1. The $6,000 Grocery Cap on Amex BCP: $$\text{Net BCP Grocery Value} = ($6,000 \times 0.06) - $95 = $360 - $95 = $265$$ On the Robinhood Gold Card, earning 3% on that same $6,000 yields: $$\text{Robinhood Gold Grocery Value} = $6,000 \times 0.03 = $180$$ On groceries alone up to the cap, Amex BCP holds an $$85$ net annual advantage.

  2. Where Robinhood Gold Overcomes BCP: On all non-category spending (utilities, insurance, medical, home improvement, vehicle repairs), Robinhood Gold earns 3% vs. Amex BCP’s 1% (a 2% margin). $$\text{Break-Even Spend} = \frac{$85}{0.02} = $4,250$$ If you spend more than $4,250 per year ($354/month) on general purchases outside of BCP’s bonus categories, the Robinhood Gold Card generates higher total annual net rewards.

Recommended Cards for This Strategy

Robinhood $0/yr

Robinhood Gold Card

Base Return 3.0%
Full Card Breakdown →
American Express $95/yr

Amex Blue Cash Preferred

Base Return 1.0%
Top Category 6x / %
Full Card Breakdown →