Direct Answer

The Southwest Rapid Rewards Plus Card ($69 AF) delivers vastly superior monetary value via 3,000 anniversary bonus points, flight redemptions, and progress toward the Southwest Companion Pass. The Disney Premier Visa ($49 AF) is strictly a niche fandom card offering 2% Disney Reward Dollars, in-park character photo ops, and Disney merchandise discounts.

  • Disney Premier costs $49/year and earns 2% Disney Rewards Dollars at grocery stores, restaurants, and gas
  • Southwest Plus costs $69/year and includes 3,000 anniversary bonus points annually (~$42 value)
  • Southwest card spend and welcome offers count toward the Southwest Companion Pass (BOGO flights)
  • Both cards are issued by JPMorgan Chase and subject to the 5/24 underwriting velocity rule

Head-to-Head Comparison

MetricDisney® Premier Visa® CardSouthwest Rapid Rewards® Plus
Annual Fee$49/year$69/year
Anniversary BonusNone3,000 points annually (~$42 flight value)
Top Reward Rate2% Disney Reward Dollars (Grocery, Dining, Gas)2x points on Southwest and transit
Redemption FlexibilityDisney merchandise, park tickets, Disney+ creditsSouthwest airline flights (no blackout dates)
Companion Pass EligibilityNoneAll points count toward Companion Pass
Park Privileges10% Disney Store discount, private photo spots2 early check-ins per year

Recommendation

Unless you visit Disney theme parks multiple times a year and value the private Disney character photo lounges, the Southwest Plus Card delivers significantly higher cash-equivalent travel utility for only $20 more per year.

Recommended Cards for This Strategy

Chase $49/yr

Disney® Premier Visa® Card

Base Return 1.0%
Top Category 5x / %
Full Card Breakdown →
Chase $99/yr

Southwest Rapid Rewards® Plus Credit Card

Base Return 0.0%
Top Category 2x / %
Full Card Breakdown →