Direct Answer

Yes, for any traveler staying at Choice hotels once per year. The $95 annual fee on the Select is completely offset by the 30,000 anniversary bonus points (worth ~$180) plus higher 10x hotel and 5x everyday multipliers.

  • Choice Privileges Select awards 30,000 anniversary bonus points every year upon renewal—worth ~$180 against the $95 fee
  • Select earns 10x points at Choice Hotels and 5x on gas, groceries, home improvement, and phone plans; Base earns 5x and 3x
  • Choice Privileges Mastercard ($0 AF) is best strictly as a zero-cost credit line keeper for occasional budget road trips
  • Choice Privileges Select includes a $100 statement credit for Global Entry or TSA PreCheck application fees

Head-to-Head Comparison

FeatureChoice Privileges Select MastercardChoice Privileges Mastercard
Annual Fee$95 annual fee$0 annual fee
Annual Anniversary Bonus30,000 bonus points every year (worth ~$180)None
Choice Hotels Spend10x points5x points
Gas, Groceries, Home, Phone5x points3x points
All Other Purchases1x point1x point
Elite Status10 Elite Night Credits (Automatic Platinum)10 Elite Night Credits (Automatic Gold)
Global Entry / TSA PreCheckUp to $100 statement credit every 4 yearsNone
Foreign Transaction Fee$0 (None)$0 (None)

The Mathematical Verdict: Why Select Always Wins

Choice Privileges points have an average baseline valuation of 0.6 cents per point.

  1. The 30,000 Point Anniversary Arbitrage: Each year when you pay the $95 annual fee on the Select card, Wells Fargo deposits 30,000 Choice Privileges points into your account.

    $$30,000 \text{ points} \times $0.006 = $180 \text{ in hotel stay value}$$

    You are effectively buying $180 worth of hotel room nights at Radisson, Cambria, Comfort Inn, or Ascend Collection properties for $95, generating an automatic net gain of $85 per year without even swiping the card.

  2. Multiplier Comparison:

    • Spending $3,000 per year at Choice Hotels earns 30,000 points ($180) on the Select vs. 15,000 points ($90) on the no-fee card.
    • Spending $6,000 on groceries, gas, and home improvement earns 30,000 points ($180) on the Select vs. 18,000 points ($108) on the base card.

The Bottom Line

Unless you refuse to stay in a Choice hotel at least once per calendar year, the Choice Privileges Select Mastercard is mathematically superior to the no-fee version in every operational metric.

Recommended Cards for This Strategy

Wells Fargo $95/yr

Choice Privileges® Select Mastercard®

Base Return 1.0%
Top Category 10x / %
Full Card Breakdown →
Wells Fargo $0/yr

Choice Privileges® Mastercard®

Base Return 1.0%
Top Category 5x / %
Full Card Breakdown →