Direct Answer

For pure Amazon purchases, the Amazon Prime Visa wins decisively with 5% cash back ($50 back on $1,000 spend) compared to the Chase Freedom Unlimited's 1.5% base rate ($15 back on $1,000 spend). Even when paired with a Sapphire Reserve (where points are worth 1.5¢ in the travel portal), the Freedom Unlimited yields only 2.25% effective value—less than half the Prime Visa. The only exception is when the Freedom Unlimited features Amazon as a rotating quarterly bonus.

  • Prime Visa delivers a permanent, uncapped 5% cash back on Amazon.com and Whole Foods
  • Chase Freedom Unlimited earns a base 1.5% cash back (1.5x Ultimate Rewards) on non-category spend
  • On a $2,000 annual Amazon spend, Prime Visa earns $100 vs. $30 on Freedom Unlimited
  • Freedom Unlimited points can be pooled with a Sapphire card for Hyatt and airline partner transfers

Head-to-Head Comparison on Amazon.com

FeaturePrime Visa (Chase)Chase Freedom Unlimited®
Annual Fee$0 (with Amazon Prime)$0
Amazon.com Purchases5% Cash Back (Permanent & Uncapped)1.5% Cash Back (1.5x Ultimate Rewards points)
Whole Foods Market5% Cash Back1.5% Cash Back
Chase Travel5% Cash Back5% Cash Back
Dining Multiplier2% Cash Back3% Cash Back
Drugstores Multiplier1% Cash Back3% Cash Back
Foreign Transaction Fee0% (None)3% of each transaction

Mathematical Point Valuation

Even if you aggressively transfer Ultimate Rewards points to luxury hotel partners:

  • Freedom Unlimited: 1.5 points per dollar $\times$ 2.0¢ peak valuation = 3.0% effective return.
  • Prime Visa: 5.0% direct cash back = 5.0% guaranteed cash return. You are sacrificing an unambiguous 2.0% in guaranteed cash margin by swiping the Freedom Unlimited on Amazon.com.

Recommended Cards for This Strategy

Chase $0/yr

Amazon Prime Visa

Base Return 1.0%
Top Category 5x / %
Full Card Breakdown →
Chase $0/yr

Chase Freedom Unlimited®

Base Return 1.5%
Top Category 5x / %
Full Card Breakdown →