Direct Answer

The Bank of America Customized Cash Rewards ($0 annual fee) is superior for online shoppers and Preferred Rewards clients with $100,000+ in assets, earning 3% to 5.25% cash back on your choice category (online shopping, dining, travel, gas, home improvement, or drugstores). The Costco Anywhere Visa by Citi ($0 card annual fee with paid Costco membership) is superior for Costco shoppers and heavy commuters, earning 4% on gas and EV charging (up to $7,000/yr), 3% on dining and travel, and 2% at Costco.

  • Costco Anywhere Visa earns 4% cash back on eligible gas and EV charging (up to $7,000/yr), 3% dining/travel, and 2% at Costco
  • BofA Customized Cash earns 3% (up to 5.25% with Preferred Rewards) on your choice category (gas, online shopping, dining, travel, home, drugstores)
  • Costco Anywhere Visa requires an active paid Costco membership ($65 or $130/yr) and only pays out cash back once per year as a certificate
  • BofA Customized Cash caps 3% and 2% bonus spend at $2,500 combined per quarter, whereas Costco gas cap is $7,000 annually

Head-to-Head Comparison

FeatureBank of America® Customized Cash RewardsCostco Anywhere Visa® Card by Citi
Card Annual Fee$0$0 (Paid Costco membership required)
Gas & EV Charging3.0% to 5.25% (If selected as choice category)4% Cash Back (up to $7,000/yr, then 1%)
Costco Wholesale Spend2.0% to 3.50% (Subject to $2,500/quarter cap)2% Cash Back (uncapped)
Online Shopping3.0% to 5.25% (Includes Amazon, Walmart, Target)1% Cash Back
Restaurants & Dining3.0% to 5.25% (or 1% if other choice selected)3% Cash Back (uncapped)
Travel3.0% to 5.25% (or 1% if other choice selected)3% Cash Back (uncapped)
Rewards PayoutMonthly deposit to any checking/savingsAnnual certificate issued in February
Foreign Transaction Fee3%0%

Warehouse Acceptance & Payout Liquidity

  1. Both Cards are Visas: Because Costco warehouses exclusively accept Visa credit cards at checkout, both cards function at Costco cash registers and Costco gas pumps without network restriction and Costco gas pumps.
  2. The Liquidity Factor:
    • The Costco Anywhere Visa locks your cash back until the close of the February billing cycle each year, issued as a physical or digital certificate that must be redeemed at a Costco warehouse register. If you close the card or cancel your Costco membership before February, you forfeit all accrued cash back.
    • The Bank of America Customized Cash pays out cash back monthly with zero expiration and can be deposited into any checking or savings account.

Strategic Verdict

— Choose Bank of America Customized Cash if you want the industry’s premier online shopping card (earning 3% to 5.25% on Amazon, online retailers, and delivery apps), or hold Platinum Honors tier with Bank of America.
— Choose Costco Anywhere Visa if you commute heavily by car (spending up to $7,000/yr on gas/EV charging), spend frequently at Costco, and don’t mind annual rewards disbursement.

Recommended Cards for This Strategy

Bank of America $0/yr

Bank of America® Customized Cash Rewards Credit Card

Base Return 1.0%
Top Category 3x / %
Full Card Breakdown →
Citi $0/yr

Costco Anywhere Visa® Card by Citi

Base Return 1.0%
Top Category 4x / %
Full Card Breakdown →