Direct Answer

The Citi Custom Cash ($0 AF) wins for most consumers by automatically awarding 5% cash back on your highest eligible spend category each billing cycle up to $500. The Bank of America Customized Cash Rewards ($0 AF) is superior for Preferred Rewards clients with $100k+ in assets, boosting its 3% selectable category to an industry-leading 5.25% cash back.

  • Citi Custom Cash automatically pays 5% on your top spend category (up to $500/billing cycle)
  • BofA Customized Cash pays 3% on a category you choose + 2% at grocery stores/wholesale clubs ($2,500/quarter cap)
  • BofA Preferred Rewards boosts rewards by 25% to 75% for banking/Merrill investment clients
  • At Platinum Honors ($100k+ assets), BofA Customized Cash earns 5.25% on selected categories and 3.5% at wholesale clubs

Head-to-Head Comparison

CategoryCiti Custom Cash® CardBofA Customized Cash RewardsBofA Platinum Honors Tier ($100k+)
Annual Fee$0$0$0
Top Category Multiplier5% Cash Back3% Cash Back5.25% Cash Back
Spending Cap$500 per billing cycle$2,500 per quarter$2,500 per quarter
Category SelectionAutomatic (Highest Spend)Manual (Select once/mo)Manual (Select once/mo)
Grocery / Wholesale Clubs1% (Unless top category)2% Cash Back3.5% Cash Back
Base Spend1% Cash Back1% Cash Back1.75% Cash Back

The Preferred Rewards Multiplier Equation

If you keep checking or Merrill investment funds with Bank of America:

  • No Tier: Citi Custom Cash wins (5% vs 3%).
  • Platinum Honors Tier ($100k+ assets): BofA multiplies all earnings by 1.75x, elevating the 3% category to 5.25% and the 2% wholesale club category to 3.5% on up to $2,500 in quarterly purchases.

Recommended Cards for This Strategy

Bank of America $0/yr

Bank of America® Customized Cash Rewards Credit Card

Base Return 1.0%
Top Category 3x / %
Full Card Breakdown →
Citi $0/yr

Citi Custom Cash® Card

Base Return 1.0%
Top Category 5x / %
Full Card Breakdown →