Direct Answer

The Choice Privileges® Select Mastercard® ($95 annual fee) is superior for guaranteed annual point value, delivering 30,000 anniversary bonus points upon renewal (worth ~$180 in hotel nights, netting +$85 over the fee) and automatic Platinum status. The Wyndham Rewards Earner® Plus ($75 annual fee) is superior for road-trippers and vacation rental bookers, granting 7,500 anniversary points, automatic Platinum status, and a 10% points discount on all award redemptions (including Vacasa vacation rentals).

  • Choice Privileges Select ($95 AF) awards 30,000 anniversary points annually worth roughly $180
  • Wyndham Earner Plus ($75 AF) provides 7,500 anniversary points and a 10% discount on award bookings
  • Both cards provide automatic mid-tier Platinum hotel status
  • Wyndham points redeem directly for Vacasa vacation rental homes at 15,000 points per bedroom

Head-to-Head Comparison

FeatureWyndham Rewards Earner® Plus CardChoice Privileges® Select Mastercard®
Annual Fee$75$95
Anniversary Points Bonus7,500 points (~$67 value)30,000 points (~$180 value)
Net Fee After Points$8 net fee ($75 - $67)-$85 net fee ($95 - $180 = +$85 Profit)
Award Night Discount10% points discount on all award bookingsNone
Elite Status GrantedPlatinum Status (Early check-in, car rental upgrades)Platinum Elite Status (20 elite night credits)
Hotel Spend Multiplier6x points at Wyndham hotels10x points at Choice hotels
Everyday Multipliers6x Gas; 4x dining & grocery5x Gas, 5x Grocery, 5x Home Improvement
Unique RedemptionVacasa vacation home rentals (15k pts/bedroom)Ascend Hotel Collection & Nordic Choice
Foreign Transaction Fee0%0%

Vacasa Vacation Rentals vs. European Choice Gems

  1. The Wyndham / Vacasa Sweet Spot: Wyndham points can be redeemed for private vacation homes managed by Vacasa at a flat 15,000 points per bedroom per night (with the Earner Plus 10% discount, this drops to 13,500 points/night). This allows travelers to book $350-$500/night mountain cabins or beach condos for a fraction of the cost.
  2. The Choice Privileges European Play: Choice points offer astonishing redemption value across Scandinavia (Clarion, Quality, and Comfort hotels in Norway and Sweden) and Japan, where 30,000 points covers 2–3 nights of lodging including complimentary full Scandinavian buffet breakfasts.

Strategic Verdict

— Choose Choice Privileges Select for the mathematically unbeatable 30,000 anniversary point bonus, providing an instant $85 profit above the annual fee.
— Choose Wyndham Rewards Earner Plus for heavy road-tripping, 6x gas station rewards, and 10% discounts on Vacasa cabin rentals.

Recommended Cards for This Strategy

Barclays $75/yr

Wyndham Rewards Earner® Plus Card

Base Return 1.0%
Top Category 6x / %
Full Card Breakdown →
Wells Fargo $95/yr

Choice Privileges® Select Mastercard®

Base Return 1.0%
Top Category 10x / %
Full Card Breakdown →