The Chase Sapphire Preferred® ($95 annual fee) is superior for overall value and point redemption, offering 3x dining, 3x online grocery, primary auto rental collision insurance, and direct 1:1 transfer partners including World of Hyatt and United Airlines. The American Express® Green Card ($150 annual fee) is superior for urban commuters and airport frequenters, providing 3x points on comprehensive transit (subways, tolls, parking, rideshares), 3x on broad travel and dining, and an annual $199 CLEAR Plus credit that fully offsets the fee.
- Amex Green ($150 AF) earns 3x points on travel, transit (subways, rideshares, tolls), and restaurants worldwide
- Sapphire Preferred ($95 AF) earns 3x dining, 3x online grocery, 2x travel, and includes a $50 annual hotel credit
- Amex Green includes an annual $199 CLEAR Plus statement credit and $100 LoungeBuddy credit
- Sapphire Preferred provides primary auto rental collision coverage; Amex Green provides secondary coverage
Side-by-side fee breakdowns, category multipliers, and transfer partner valuations.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Feature | American Express® Green Card | Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Fee | $150 | $95 |
| Transit Multiplier | 3x Points (Subways, trains, tolls, ferries, parking) | 2x Points (Under travel category) |
| Dining Multiplier | 3x Points worldwide | 3x Points worldwide |
| Online Grocery Multiplier | 1x Points | 3x Points (Includes Instacart, Kroger) |
| Travel Multiplier | 3x Points (Air, hotels, vacation rentals, tours) | 2x direct / 5x via Chase Travel portal |
| Annual Statement Credits | Up to $199 CLEAR Plus & $100 LoungeBuddy | $50 Hotel Credit (Chase Travel) |
| Car Rental Protection | Secondary coverage | Primary Worldwide Collision Damage Waiver |
| Transfer Program | Amex Membership Rewards® | Chase Ultimate Rewards® |
| Foreign Transaction Fee | 0% | 0% |
The CLEAR Plus Valuation Break-Even
The Amex Green card’s financial viability hinges on whether you use airport CLEAR Plus security:
- CLEAR Plus Membership Retail Cost: $199/year.
- The Amex Green provides an annual $199 statement credit covering the full fee.
- If you use CLEAR Plus: $$\text{Net Effective Fee} = $150 - $199 = -$49.00\text{ (Net Profit)}$$
- If you never use CLEAR: You are paying an ongoing $150 annual fee ($55 higher than the Sapphire Preferred) while receiving secondary car rental coverage.
Strategic Verdict
— Choose American Express Green if you commute daily via subways/tolls/trains, travel through airports with CLEAR Plus lanes, and value broad 3x transit rewards.
— Choose Chase Sapphire Preferred if you want primary rental car insurance, 3x online grocery bonuses, and transfer access to World of Hyatt and domestic airlines.