Direct Answer

The Chase Sapphire Preferred® ($95 annual fee) is superior for overall value and point redemption, offering 3x dining, 3x online grocery, primary auto rental collision insurance, and direct 1:1 transfer partners including World of Hyatt and United Airlines. The American Express® Green Card ($150 annual fee) is superior for urban commuters and airport frequenters, providing 3x points on comprehensive transit (subways, tolls, parking, rideshares), 3x on broad travel and dining, and an annual $199 CLEAR Plus credit that fully offsets the fee.

  • Amex Green ($150 AF) earns 3x points on travel, transit (subways, rideshares, tolls), and restaurants worldwide
  • Sapphire Preferred ($95 AF) earns 3x dining, 3x online grocery, 2x travel, and includes a $50 annual hotel credit
  • Amex Green includes an annual $199 CLEAR Plus statement credit and $100 LoungeBuddy credit
  • Sapphire Preferred provides primary auto rental collision coverage; Amex Green provides secondary coverage

Head-to-Head Comparison

FeatureAmerican Express® Green CardChase Sapphire Preferred® Card
Annual Fee$150$95
Transit Multiplier3x Points (Subways, trains, tolls, ferries, parking)2x Points (Under travel category)
Dining Multiplier3x Points worldwide3x Points worldwide
Online Grocery Multiplier1x Points3x Points (Includes Instacart, Kroger)
Travel Multiplier3x Points (Air, hotels, vacation rentals, tours)2x direct / 5x via Chase Travel portal
Annual Statement CreditsUp to $199 CLEAR Plus & $100 LoungeBuddy$50 Hotel Credit (Chase Travel)
Car Rental ProtectionSecondary coveragePrimary Worldwide Collision Damage Waiver
Transfer ProgramAmex Membership Rewards®Chase Ultimate Rewards®
Foreign Transaction Fee0%0%

The CLEAR Plus Valuation Break-Even

The Amex Green card’s financial viability hinges on whether you use airport CLEAR Plus security:

  • CLEAR Plus Membership Retail Cost: $199/year.
  • The Amex Green provides an annual $199 statement credit covering the full fee.
  • If you use CLEAR Plus: $$\text{Net Effective Fee} = $150 - $199 = -$49.00\text{ (Net Profit)}$$
  • If you never use CLEAR: You are paying an ongoing $150 annual fee ($55 higher than the Sapphire Preferred) while receiving secondary car rental coverage.

Strategic Verdict

— Choose American Express Green if you commute daily via subways/tolls/trains, travel through airports with CLEAR Plus lanes, and value broad 3x transit rewards.
— Choose Chase Sapphire Preferred if you want primary rental car insurance, 3x online grocery bonuses, and transfer access to World of Hyatt and domestic airlines.

Recommended Cards for This Strategy

American Express $150/yr

Amex Green Card

Base Return 0.0%
Top Category 3x / %
Full Card Breakdown →
Chase $95/yr

Chase Sapphire Preferred

Base Return 0.0%
Top Category 5x / %
Full Card Breakdown →