Direct Answer

The Amex EveryDay Card ($0 AF) is a flexible consumer rewards card earning transferable Membership Rewards points with a 20% transaction bonus. The IHG One Rewards Premier ($99 AF) is a travel powerhouse that easily offsets its fee with an annual Free Night Certificate (up to 40,000 points) and automatic IHG Platinum Elite status.

  • Amex EveryDay has a $0 annual fee and keeps Amex Membership Rewards points alive indefinitely
  • IHG Premier ($99 AF) gives an annual Free Night Certificate worth up to $250+ at InterContinental/Kimpton hotels
  • IHG Premier includes automatic Platinum Elite hotel status and a 4th night free on award stays
  • Amex EveryDay grants a 20% points bonus when you make 20 or more purchases in a billing period

Head-to-Head Comparison

FeatureAmex EveryDay® Credit CardIHG One Rewards Premier Credit Card
Annual Fee$0$99/year
Primary CurrencyAmex Membership Rewards (Transferable)IHG One Rewards Points (Hotel Specific)
Annual Free NightNone1 Free Night Certificate annually (up to 40k pts)
Hotel Elite StatusNoneAutomatic Platinum Elite Status
Supermarket Spend2x points (up to $6,000/yr)5x points (approx. 2.5% return)
Hotel Spend1x pointUp to 26x total points at IHG Hotels
4th Night Free BenefitNoneBook 3 award nights, get 4th night free
Foreign Transaction Fee2.7%$0 (None)

Economic Assessment

  1. The IHG Premier ROI: The IHG Premier Card carries a $99 annual fee, but it provides an Anniversary Free Night Certificate redeemable at properties costing up to 40,000 points (with the ability to top off with unlimited additional points). Redeeming this certificate at high-tier Kimpton, InterContinental, or Hotel Indigo properties regularly yields $200 to $350 in value, making the card mathematically positive to hold year after year.

  2. The Amex EveryDay Purpose: The Amex EveryDay card is designed as a $0 annual fee anchor. If you hold an Amex Platinum or Gold card and wish to cancel them without forfeiting your accumulated Membership Rewards balance, downgrading or opening the Amex EveryDay preserves your points bank and transfer access with zero carry cost.

Recommended Cards for This Strategy

American Express $0/yr

Amex EveryDay

Base Return 0.0%
Top Category 2x / %
Full Card Breakdown →
Chase $99/yr

IHG One Rewards Premier Credit Card

Base Return 0.0%
Top Category 5x / %
Full Card Breakdown →