Direct Answer

Prime Visa ($0 AF with Prime) completely dominates for Amazon.com, Whole Foods, and travel with 5% cash back. Amex Cash Magnet ($0 AF) serves as a secondary card earning 1.5% on categories outside of Amazon's ecosystem.

  • Prime Visa earns 5% back at Amazon.com, Amazon Fresh, Whole Foods, and Chase Travel with no earnings cap
  • Prime Visa also earns 2% on restaurants, gas stations, and transit, beating Cash Magnet's 1.5% on those categories
  • Cash Magnet offers 1.5% on miscellaneous non-Amazon retail and has broader introductory 0% APR financing periods
  • Prime Visa requires an active Amazon Prime subscription to unlock the full 5% cash back rate

Head-to-Head Comparison

FeaturePrime Visa (Chase)American Express Cash Magnet®
Annual Fee$0 ($139/yr Amazon Prime required)$0 annual fee (No subscription needed)
Amazon.com & Whole Foods5% cash back (Uncapped)1.5% cash back
Chase Travel5% cash back1.5% cash back
Restaurants & Gas Stations2% cash back1.5% cash back
Local Transit & Commuting2% cash back1.5% cash back
All Other Purchases1% cash back1.5% cash back
Foreign Transaction Fee$0 (None)2.7%
Network & ProtectionsVisa Signature (Extended Warranty, Baggage Delay)American Express Traditional

The Verdict

For any existing Amazon Prime member, the Prime Visa is superior across almost every category, earning 5% at Amazon/Whole Foods and 2% on gas, dining, and transit. The only reason to hold the Cash Magnet is if you do not subscribe to Amazon Prime, or want 1.5% on general non-bonus retail.

Recommended Cards for This Strategy

Chase $0/yr

Amazon Prime Visa

Base Return 1.0%
Top Category 5x / %
Full Card Breakdown →
American Express $0/yr

Amex Cash Magnet

Base Return 0.0%
Full Card Breakdown →